Gewinner Elfmeterpokal
| Jahr | Name | Verein | Torwart |
| 2011 | Mick Beusenberg | FC Twente | Stefan Postma |
| 2010 | Fedor Chalov | CSKA Moskau | Joost Terol |
| 2009 | Donny van de Beek | AJAX | Sander Boschker |
| 2008 | Raymond de Waard | AZ | Raymond Lenting |
| 2007 | Milan Bultman | FC Twente/Heracles | Jim van Fessem |
| 2006 | Mohamed Rayhi | PSV | Jurgen Wevers |
| 2005 | Jannik Cools | PSV | Jelle ten Rouwelaar |
| 2004 | Tobias Portmann | Schalke 04 | Sander Boschker |
| 2003 | Bjorn Bussman | 1. FC Köln | Sander Boschker |